- Resident Evil 4 - 35
- Shadow of the Colossus - 6 (including 2 awards from 2006)
- God of War - 4
- Civilization IV - 3
- F.E.A.R. - 3
- Psychonauts - 3
- Battlefield 2 - 1
- Burnout Revenge - 1
- Digital Devil Saga - 1
- Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas - 1 (counted toward 2004)
- Guild Wars - 1
- Guitar Hero - 1
- Halo 2 - 1 (counted toward 2004)
- Jade Empire - 1
- Myst V: End of Ages - 1
- Tekken 5 - 1
Winners by Media Outlet
- G4TV G-phoria 2005 (US): Halo 2
- Golden Joysticks (UK) : Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas
- St. Petersburg Times (US) : Guitar Hero
- Gamesmagazine-online (UK) : Psychonauts
- San Jose Mercury News (US) : Burnout Revenge
- Spike TV Video Game Awards (US) : Resident Evil 4
- River Front Times (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Gamer 2.0 (US) : God of War
- Edge Magazine (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- GamePro (US) : Resident Evil 4
- BC Magazine (US) : Resident Evil 4
- DarkZero (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- Actiontrip (US) : F.E.A.R.
- Actiontrip People's Choice (US) : F.E.A.R.
- NeoGAF (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Gametrailers (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Cheat Code Central (US) : Resident Evil 4
- X-Play (US) : Resident Evil 4
- GameZone (US) : Resident Evil 4
- GAMEZ.LV (LV) : Civilization IV
- GameSpot (US) : Resident Evil 4
- GameSpot Reader's Choice GOTY (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Ars Technica (US) : Shadow of the Colossus
- Gamespy (US) : Civilization IV
- GameFAQs (US) : Resident Evil 4
- IGN (US) : God of War
- IGN Reader's Choice GOTY (US) : Resident Evil 4
- 4PLAYER.DE (DE) : Resident Evil 4
- Diehard Gamefan (US) : Digital Devil Saga
- Game Informer (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Gamedaily (US) : God of War
- WorthPlaying (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Game-Revolution (US) : Resident Evil 4
- ZTGD (US) : Resident Evil 4
- PALGN (AU) : Resident Evil 4
- PALGN Reader's Choice (Au) : Resident Evil 4
- UGO (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Eurogamer (UK) : Psychonauts
- Eurogamer Reader's Choice GOTY (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- NZGamer (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Shacknews (US) : Battlefield 2
- Thunderbolt (US/UK) : Resident Evil 4
- 1UP (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Chicago Tribune (US) : Resident Evil 4
- TechWhack (IN) : Psychonauts
- Pittsburgh Post-Gazette (US) : Resident Evil 4
- Fragland (BE) : Civilization IV
- AIAS (US) : God of War
- Game Developers Choice Awards (US) : Shadow of the Colossus
- GamesRader (US) : Shadow of the Colossus
- e-AAGH.net (US) : Tekken 5
- GAME.co.uk (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- GAME.co.uk People's Choice Awards (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- Game Industry News (US) : Myst V: End of Ages
- NTSC-uk (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- NTSC-uk Reader's Choice GOTY (UK) : Resident Evil 4
- GameFly Q Awards (US) : Resident Evil 4
- MegaGames (US) : F.E.A.R.
- Canadian New Media Awards (CA) : Jade Empire
- NAViGaTR AWARDS (US) : Shadow of the Colossus
- Box Office Prophet - Calvin Awards (US) : Resident Evil 4
- GameShot (KR): Guild Wars
